First Impressions
Readers assured me I would love this novel and I did! I don't know how to begin to explain how much I loved it, but I'm going to try. I laughed and cried so many times reading "The Correspondent," Virginia Evans's debut novel. When I mentioned it in a previous video, a viewer commented that they were sure I'd love it, and that it was the most "Eric" book they had ever come across. They were completely right. I fell for this book totally.
Sybil and Her Letters
The story follows Sybil Van Antwerp, a woman in her seventies who has just let her hair go naturally gray and who spends almost all of her time writing letters, as she has done throughout her life. It's a story about love, regret and grief, and I connected with it very strongly, because I feel like Sybil. I've been a keen letter writer for much of my life. Not so much in recent years, but as a teenager I kept pen pals all over the world, and reading this book sent me down memory lane. I went through the dusty old box of letters I still have. I used to have bags and bags of them, but I cut them down because I couldn't physically carry them from place to place.
The novel explains very clearly why some personalities feel more comfortable expressing themselves through letters. There's a sense of control in sitting down to encapsulate your thoughts in a way you can't manage in person, and a way of expressing yourself that feels truer than speaking. When I talk with people in social situations there are things I want to say that get jumbled in my head, but when I'm writing I can set everything out clearly. Letters have a formality, and they create intense closeness while also keeping a physical distance. That's exactly what Sybil grapples with in her relationships: how close she feels to people and how much she wants to maintain distance.
A Web of Correspondence
We follow her as she writes to family, friends and loved ones, to people she hates, and to large organisations we think of as faceless, such as corporations and universities, which are actually made up of people. The story runs over roughly a decade from 2012, and some of the letters are intimate while others are formal. Part of the pleasure is that her personality gradually emerges from the letters she sends and receives. She adjusts her tone for each person, as we all do, so we come to know her deeply. We also see her steelier side in skirmishes with her local gardening club, which are hilarious, and in her frustrations with organisations, where formal messages gradually soften into more familiar correspondence as she builds deeper connections with an acquaintance, a neighbour, or a man she knows only briefly.
She has also kept up a long friendship with a woman she has known for much of her life. They are both keen readers, and their letters are full of the books they're reading. One of the great joys of the novel is her correspondence with real authors. For instance, she writes to Ann Patchett, Kazuo Ishiguro, Larry McMurtry and Joan Didion, and in some cases they write back, with their letters reproduced in the story. It's a fictional construct, of course, though I wonder whether Evans wrote to some of these authors herself. I related to it strongly, because I used to do the same.
My Own Letters to Authors
Early on I wrote to the playwright Edward Albee, who has sadly since died, and he wrote back. I tried to find his letters while going through my old ones, and I don't know where they've gone – it’s so frustrating that I’ve somehow lost them. He was really kind to write back. I also wrote to the Canadian author Joan Barfoot. Before I did all this bookish stuff online, I would buy advance copies of books from used book sites before they were published, which I know you're not supposed to sell or buy, but I was so excited to read them. One was Barfoot's "Luck," and I was so struck by it that I wrote to her. She wrote back, amused that I'd read a book that wasn't out yet, but she was grateful and lovely about it.
I also wrote very early on to my favourite author of all time, Joyce Carol Oates. I had written my master's thesis partly on her novel "Blonde" and partly on Susan Sontag's "In America," and I very boldly sent it to her. She sent a lovely postcard back, and what strikes me is that she wrote it on September 11th, 2001. It blows my mind that she sat down to write a kind response about my little thesis while all that news was unfolding in the background. I've since maintained a connection with her and interviewed her several times on my channel. That's a tangent, but it's a special thing.
Mystery, Romance and Suspense
The novel is several things at once, and it's suspenseful because multiple mysteries arise. One storyline involves someone writing threatening letters to her and stalking her, so there's the mystery of that person's identity. There's also an unsent letter that she has been writing for a very long time, and who it's addressed to and why only becomes clear later. It's a love story too, a kind of love triangle with something of Jane Austen about it, and she mentions reading Austen in the book. Sybil has two suitors she wasn't expecting. She has long been divorced and felt she was done with that part of her life, but she finds herself attracted to both men, which takes her off guard.
At first it felt a little disorienting because there are so many characters, and so many letters going back and forth. But the novel is good at laying out who everyone is, and once I understood the network of people she writes to, I was gripped. It felt like a very classy literary soap opera. With each letter the suspense grows, and I wanted to know how people would respond and what the next letter would say, even though it would move on to another storyline. I liked how it kept circling back to certain relationships and plotlines that built over the course of the story.
Letters in Real Time
Letter writing happens in real time. Things occur in the world while letters are being written and in the gaps while they're in the post, so we're aware of time moving forward in a way that differs from a third-person narrative, which can jump back and forth. Here the progression is almost completely linear. There's a very charming interlude when a long-term friend sends her letters she wrote early in her life, which are reproduced in the novel. Her personality is already there, but she's more naive and precocious, and I thought that was so sweet.
I'm also a sucker for cross-generational friendships, and one storyline follows the long friendship she maintains with the son of an older friend, a teenage boy who is struggling with a number of issues. They build a very tender friendship.
Words as Companions
I loved this book because it's all about reading, literature and the written word as a companion, and how we reach out to other people through words. It's about the things we want to say, the things we find hard to say, and sometimes the things we can't say because by the time we're ready, it's too late. The way the story grapples with that, in such a dynamic and heartfelt way, I find beautiful and powerful. So much of it is about our shared humanity and about building connections, and about how some antagonistic connections can be unlocked through communication and opening up to each other.
It's also sophisticated in how it mimics sending and receiving letters over time, across different media. She prefers written letters, but she also sends emails, and she's conscious that her tone changes in them, because email feels more fleeting and brisk.
There's an overarching tragedy: Sybil is steadily going blind. She knows she won't be able to keep writing and receiving letters in the way she's used to, and it will affect her ability to read both the letters and the books she loves so much. That's heartbreaking, but it forces her to reckon with what her life has been made of. Many of us who find it easier to communicate from a distance, through letters rather than in person, wrestle with this. She looks around at the mass of accumulated letters and wonders what her life amounts to, just scraps of paper. But there's an expression of herself that remains in all those letters, with an immediacy and power that I don't think other forms of narrative can achieve, even a first-person narrative. Reading other people's letters gives you a little insight into a particular moment, into their personality, and into their relationship with the person they're writing to. That's why epistolary novels are so unique and why I'm such a sucker for them.
There aren't many epistolary novels anymore, but the book references Helene Hanff's "84, Charing Cross Road," which isn't a novel but which I reread at the beginning of this year. I think its endurance comes from the strong sense of its writers' personalities, and the way every level of what makes us human is encapsulated in those letters.
Verdict
This is a beautiful, wonderful, perfect-for-me novel and I can't say enough good things about it. I was really sad when it ended, not only because of the way the plot builds and concludes, but because I didn't have more letters to read. I'll miss it, though I'll enjoy returning to it. I'm not sure whether I'd want Evans to write a sequel, since it's always tricky whether something should be extended, but I grew to love so many of the characters that I'd love to read a lot more of their letters. I was thrilled to see it win the Women’s Prize earlier this year.
If you've read it, I'd love to hear how you related to it. Did you write and receive letters throughout your life, or emails, or whatever level of correspondence you like to keep? I really miss having pen pals, and I know some people have started writing letters again after reading this novel. Maybe I will too. There's a concentration that comes with sitting down to write a physical letter that you don't get from a quick email, text or WhatsApp. If you're interested in reading it now, I hope I've sold it to you, because I think it's a tremendous novel.